DNA Properties Indy

Real estate runs in the family!

  • Home
    • Before & After Gallery
  • About
    • Contact DNA Properties Indy
    • Real Estate Expert Witness Indianapolis
  • Buy
    • Resources for Buyers
    • Resources for Investors
    • Property Research Toolkit
    • Military & Guard Families
  • Neighborhoods
    • Bates-Hendricks
    • University Heights
    • Garfield Park
    • South Side & Perry Township
    • Greenwood
  • Sell
    • Featured Listings
  • Rent
  • 317-721-5310

Indianapolis Homes for Rent

Looking for a rental home in Indianapolis? DNA Properties Indy offers clean, well-maintained homes across south and near-southside neighborhoods close to downtown or the University of Indianapolis.

Pets are considered case by case, and our rentals are managed by local owners who care about their tenants.


Table of Contents

Toggle
    • Why Rent with DNA Properties Indy
  • Indianapolis Rentals
    • Renting Near the University of Indianapolis
  • Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
    • Q: What are the minimum application requirements?
    • Q: How much is the security deposit?
    • Q: Do you allow pets?
    • Q: How long is the typical lease?
    • Q: What happens during move-in and move-out?
    • Q: How can I see a home?
    • Q: What utilities or maintenance are tenants responsible for?
    • Q: Do you offer a tenant referral program?
    • Q: What should I know about the condition of the homes?

Why Rent with DNA Properties Indy

  • Locally owned and operated in Indianapolis
  • Responsive communication and clear expectations
  • Well-maintained homes near the University of Indianapolis and the Old Southside
  • Simple application and move-in process
  • Transparent pricing and lease terms
Gretchen Szostak, managing broker of DNA Properties

Indianapolis Rentals

All of our homes are currently rented. Please check back soon for new availability.

Old Southside rental home living room DNA Properties Indy

1749 S Delaware St, Indianapolis, IN 46225
3 beds • 1 bath • Old Southside neighborhood
Monthly rent: $1,800.00
1,974 square feet (approximate)
Home office
Private, fenced backyard
1-car detached garage
Rent includes: refrigerator, stove, microwave, washer, dryer

Rented/Not Available for Showings


Front of a small home with a picket fence and landscaped yard
Long living room with hardwood floors, chandelier and fireplace
Open living and dining rooms with hardwood floors and wood trim
Living room with hardwood floors and original wood trim
Dining room with built-in wood cabinet and hardwood floors
Dining room with chandelier and hardwood floors
Living room with hardwood floors and antique wood mantel
Open living space with hardwood floors and vintage furniture
Bedroom with hardwood floors, ceiling fan and wood door
Living room with hardwood floors and original wood doors
Bright room with hardwood floors and tall windows
Bathroom with jetted tub and granite vanity
Bathroom with walk-in shower and granite vanity
Empty room with hardwood floors and ceiling fan
Bedroom with hardwood floors, ceiling fan and wood trim
Bright kitchen with island, bar stools and green trim
Kitchen with blue island, bar stools and red cabinets
Yellow kitchen with blue island and stainless appliances
Colorful kitchen with blue island and red cabinets
Laundry area with stacked washer and dryer
Upstairs bedroom with sloped ceiling and hardwood floors
Upstairs bedroom with ceiling fan and wood doors
Carpeted attic bonus room with built-in shelves
Finished attic room with carpet and round window
Unfinished basement with exposed pipes and storage
Courtyard garden with fountain and wood deck
Covered porch overlooking a shaded garden courtyard
Backyard courtyard with fountain and garden beds
Shaded patio with fountain beside the house
Side yard patio with brick pavers and wood fence
Cluttered garage interior with shelving and a roll-up door
Front of a cottage-style home with a garden and small fence
Side of a house with a garden path

Renting Near the University of Indianapolis

If you study or work at the University of Indianapolis, our properties offer an ideal location. We have helped many students find comfortable housing just minutes from campus. Our rentals typically feature off-street parking, easy access to I-65, and quiet, walkable neighborhoods.

Tip: Start your search early, as UIndy-area rentals fill quickly each semester.


Indianapolis homes for rent near University of Indianapolis

1434 E Edwards Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46227
4 bedrooms • 2 bathrooms • University Heights neighborhood, a few blocks from UIndy
Monthly rent: $1,900.00
Security deposit: $2,850.00
Cleaning fee: $400 one-time, non-refundable, due upfront (per house)
1,768 square feet (approximate)
Central air
New windows and LVP flooring
In-unit laundry
Covered porch, partially fenced yard, and fire pit
2-car detached garage
1-car attached garage
Rent includes: refrigerator, stove, dishwasher, washer, dryer
Cats and dogs considered case by case with prior written approval and a signed pet agreement. Per pet: $300 refundable pet deposit, a $300 one-time non-refundable pet fee, plus $25/month pet rent.
1-year lease. Application fee: $35 through Zillow (covers 30 days). Minimum 700 credit score. Non-student applicants need 3 months of pay stubs; student applicants need a qualified guarantor.

Rented/Not Available for Showings


Empty living room with dark wood-look flooring and natural light
Empty living room with dark flooring and multiple windows
Living room with dark wood-look floors and gray walls
Open living area with dark flooring and sunlit windows
Kitchen with white cabinets and dark countertops
White kitchen with dark countertops and wood-look floor
Kitchen with white cabinets, double sink and dark counters
Empty bedroom with ceiling fan and dark flooring
Bright bedroom with ceiling fan and two windows
Bathroom with tub and white vanity
Carpeted bedroom with ceiling fan
Carpeted bedroom with ceiling fan and window
Backyard with white detached garage
Fenced backyard with fire pit and benches
Interior of a large detached garage with wood rafters
Detached white garage in a grassy backyard

Indianapolis homes for rent near University of Indianapolis

1633 Lawrence Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46227
4 bedrooms • 2 bathrooms • University Heights neighborhood
Monthly rent: $1,648.00
1,892 finished square feet (approximate)
3-car detached garage
Rent includes: refrigerator, stove, washer, dryer

Rented/Not Available for Showings


Driveway leading to a detached garage beside a deck

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: What are the minimum application requirements?

A: Applicants must provide a valid government-issued ID, verifiable income, and pass background and credit checks. Non-student tenants aged 18 and older must have a minimum credit score of 700 and provide 3 months of pay stubs. Student tenants must show proof of enrollment at an accredited university and have a qualified guarantor; students with a qualified guarantor don’t need to provide pay stubs.

Q: How much is the security deposit?

A: The standard security deposit is $2,000, though it may be higher depending on the property’s size, updates, or rental price. It must be paid in full to reserve a property and is due before move-in. There is also a one-time, non-refundable cleaning fee of $400 per house, due upfront. For each approved pet, there is a $300 refundable pet deposit and a one-time, non-refundable $300 pet fee, in addition to the security deposit, plus $25/month pet rent.

Q: Do you allow pets?

A: Some homes are pet-friendly, and pets are considered case by case. When you apply, please tell us about each pet: type, breed, age, and weight. Every pet needs prior written approval and a signed pet agreement. Pets must be housebroken and current on rabies vaccinations, and animals other than dogs and cats must be kept caged. Each approved pet has a $300 refundable pet deposit, a one-time, non-refundable $300 pet fee, plus $25/month pet rent.

Q: How long is the typical lease?

A: Most leases are 12 months, with renewal options for tenants in good standing.

Q: What happens during move-in and move-out?

A: Tenants complete a detailed walk-through inspection form at move-in and again at move-out to ensure fairness.

Q: How can I see a home?

A: For-sale listings: Call or text me at 317-721-5310 to set up a showing, or have your agent schedule one. Before a showing, I’ll need a pre-qualification letter from your lender. Indiana law also requires a signed buyer agency agreement before any showing. If you don’t have an agent yet, I’m happy to help with both. Rentals: Rentals are available for preview during the times listed on Zillow, during open houses or with your own agent.

Q: What utilities or maintenance are tenants responsible for?

A: Tenants are responsible for paying all utilities and for maintaining the lawn, landscaping, and snow removal unless otherwise specified in the lease agreement.

Q: Do you offer a tenant referral program?

A: Yes. We offer a $200 referral fee per house (not per tenant) to student tenants who refer new student tenants who sign a lease for one year or longer.
For example, if two student tenants refer two new student tenants who each lease a property for at least a year, we’ll pay $100 to each referring tenant. To qualify, the new tenants must note the referring tenant’s name on their application. Referral payments are issued after the new tenants have paid their deposit and first month’s rent.

Q: What should I know about the condition of the homes?

A: Most of our rental homes are older properties that have been renovated and are kept in good condition by their owners. Homes with basements are typically unfinished and not waterproofed, so light water intrusion may occur during heavy rain. These basements have drains and/or sump pumps to manage water flow, and the amount is generally minimal—making them suitable for limited storage. All properties are rented as-is, and we strive to ensure they remain safe, clean, and well-maintained.

Google Reviews

Excellent
DNA Properties Indy5.0
Based on 17 reviews
See all reviews
review us on
Johnathan Wilson
2 months ago
Gretchen did a great job selling my house. She coached me on the best steps to take to get the most for the sale, and I ended up selling higher than my asking price. Highly recommend!
KJ M
4 months ago
Allow me to highlight just three of Gretchen’s best realtor attributes, all of which are immediately apparent upon meeting her: her integrity, her responsiveness, and her ambition. Not only did she make sure that our family’s interests were always protected, Gretchen also does what is right for everyone involved. She kept us informed with every step, and that made everything feel a hands-off for us as the sellers as possible! At times I think she cared more about selling our house than we did, and we are SO grateful for her passion. If you are looking for a personable and thorough realtor, Gretchen is an obvious choice!
Response from the owner:Thank you so much for this thoughtful review! It was a true pleasure working with your family, and I’m so glad I could help make the process go smoothly. Your kind words about integrity, communication, and passion mean a great deal to me! Thank you for trusting me with your home, and I wish you much happiness on your new adventure!
Nick Reinhart
1 year ago
Damian was a huge help while searching for my first house! Very responsive to all my questions, and helped me navigate the process like a pro, and trusted friend. Highly recommend Damian for anyone looking to purchase!
Response from the owner:Nick, I really enjoyed working with you and think you ended up in a great house! Thanks for the review.
Anthony Gochenour
1 year ago
I worked with Damian to sell my house in Indiana while living full time across the country in Arizona, and I cannot speak highly enough of his work. He went above and beyond in every way, providing exceptional recommendations on repairs and prep for listing the property, helping to coordinate contractors and access to the property, and always being ready to handle every issue that came up throughout the process. He was very knowledgeable and developed an excellent strategy that allowed me to get the most out of the sale during a tumultuous time in the real estate market, while always prioritizing my preferences and comfort. Selling my property while not physically being there caused lots of unusual hurdles, but having Damian on my side made everything go as smoothly as possible, and I felt confident working through each step knowing I could trust and count on him.
Response from the owner:Thank you Tony! I'm glad you trusted me to sell your beautiful home and help guide you through what I think resulted in a great purchase price. I'd be happy to work with you again!
davidguest7
2 years ago
A realtor is good but also having an expert in staging is better. I'd say Gretchen's expertise and opinion got me 10k more than what the exact floorplan in my subdivision received just six weeks earlier. Very pleased with her outstanding work for me.
Response from the owner:Thank you so much, David! I really appreciate it and your willingness to trust my judgment. It helped that you had some great pieces to add to the staging and kept your home looking nice throughout the listing period. Best of luck to you in your new home!
Angela O'Neill
4 years ago
Gretchen and Damien were extremely helpful as always with our latest purchase. We have been working with them for several years to buy and sell investment properties. I trust and value their advice on areas in Indianapolis and comps. Additionally Gretchen is always looking out for us at closings to ensure everything is correct and has caught errors that saved us money more than once. We highly recommend their services.
Emily Szostak
4 years ago
Damian and Gretchen just helped us sell our house and we couldn't be more pleased. They helped us every step of the way from assisting with contractors to staging to helping us navigate the offers. Once we had the house listed, we had it sold in less then 36 hours and closed 3 weeks later. They helped make the whole process a breeze. If you are in a need of a relator, they are definitely the way to go!
Response from the owner:Thank you for trusting us to sell your beautiful home!
thomas degraff
4 years ago
I’ve worked with DNA as an out of state RE investor for 4+ years, and from distances over 4000miles. From a military service member perspective, they are very dependable and available after hours for advice with a sale or purchase.
Response from the owner:Thanks, Thom! Congratulations on the recent sale of your building, and we love working with you too!
victor zarco
5 years ago
the best experience is ... they don't just want to sell you a house ... they care about your long-term profit and satisfaction ... before you make a decision they explain you in an excellent way so that you understand each important point...thanks DNA Properties
Response from the owner:Thank you, Victor! I love working with you too and hope you love the house!
Dylan Sowa
6 years ago
Very responsive, and positive.
Response from the owner:It was very nice working with you, Dylan! You got a very good investment!
Angela Kauffman
7 years ago
Gretchen is a great realtor for investors. She is always on top of every part of the transaction and helps you sort through what is worth doing and what is not as an investor. We've bought and sold several properties with her and it has always been a great experience!
Response from the owner:Thank you so much for the kind words! I really appreciate it.
Peter Szostak
7 years ago
The best realtor there is! Very helpful through the process and will hold the other side accountable. This can save you thousands.
Response from the owner:Thanks for the support, Peter! In real estate, we treat our clients like family, especially when they are! If you need anything from us in the future, we're here for you! -Gretchen S., Owner
Liz Murphy
7 years ago
Gretchen Szostak is the only realtor I will work with after having the pleasure of working with her on two home purchases and one sale. She is bright, professional, and a hard-working advocate for her clients. Her love for homes is evident in every step she takes to find her clients exactly what they want for the best deal possible.
Response from the owner:I'm honored to be your first line of defense, Liz! You should get exactly what you're looking for when it comes to your home, and I'll do anything to make that happen. It's always awesome working with you! -Gretchen
Ricky Anderson
7 years ago
Gretchen is an excellent person and amazing to work with. She won't stop until everything is resolved and you are content. An absolute delight.
Response from the owner:Thank you so much for the kind words! It was a pleasure working with you.
Scott Surface
7 years ago
Response from the owner:Thank you, Scott! I appreciate the rating :)
Joan Groves
8 years ago
Response from the owner:Thank you!
sean garner
8 years ago
Gretchen has been very helpful in selling our house and buying another one she is very quick to response time and on top of everything!!
Response from the owner:Thanks, Sean! It was great working with you and Brittney and I’m excited to see the house once it’s finished.

Copyright © 2026 · DNA Properties Indy · 317-721-5310 · Gretchen@DNAPropertiesIndy.com.